@widgetc wrote:
I once knew someone that genuinely tried to run a business but had losses for 4 consecutive years. The CRA invalidated the the busiiness loss claims on the basis that in spite of intentions there was no reasonable epectation of ever turning a profit so it was not really a business.
I believe I reported losses from 2005 to 2015 (jewellery sales), but they weren't going to invalidate my business as a "hobby" because of how much I was selling at the market. Part of having losses was due to growing the business (or attempting to), so my sales were increasing each year until they stopped... and then I switched and started selling coins, then I started selling stamps. I expect to have a zero net income for 2025 after all the allowable deductions. But I paid tax on profit for the last three consecutive years, so not too worried about CRA.
If someone is reporting thousands of dollars of loss and only a couple hundred in income, I see them invalidating that. When you're reporting $12,000 in sales and $14,000 in expenses, they're not going to say "you're just a hobby". The more money I make, the more I spend, the more I sell, the more inventory I buy to replace what's sold. I buy a lot of consumable items for my various businesses.
C.