eBay Canada - a breakdown of the business structure - can it survive?

Interesting information below from ChatGPT regarding eBay and the Canadian site/market in terms of business ownership and management. In the new world reality we're facing, if eBay doesn't change its structure for Canada I can't see it surviving more than 2 years. This info speaks volumes to the issues we're all having trying to make things work on the platform.

Q: There seems to be little business ownership within the eBay structure for Canada. Is it mostly led by US business owners?

eBay Canada does exist as a local market entity, but its business ownership and product leadership are overwhelmingly U.S.-centric. Canada is largely managed as an extension of the U.S. business rather than a fully autonomous regional organization, and that shapes how features, marketing, and policy are handled.

Here’s a detailed breakdown of how and why this happens:

---

eBay Canada’s actual structure

eBay Canada operates under eBay Marketplaces GmbH / eBay Inc., headquartered in San Jose, California.

It maintains a small, localized marketing and partnerships team in Canada (historically based in Toronto), but product, policy, and engineering decisions are made at the U.S. global headquarters.

The Canadian team’s role is generally market enablement — local promotions, partnerships (e.g. with Canada Post or Purolator), seller engagement, and translation/localization support — not platform ownership.

So, eBay.ca is technically a separate site, but it runs on the same U.S. infrastructure and product roadmap.

---

1. Product and feature ownership

Most major eBay product verticals (search, checkout, payments, seller tools, advertising) have global or U.S.-based owners.
When features roll out to Canada, they’re usually:

Tier 2 markets after U.S. pilot testing.

Subject to minor Canadian overrides (currency, taxes, shipping, bilingual UI).

There’s typically no dedicated product manager for “Canada’s marketplace experience.” Instead, the Canadian site is supported by the same North America product team responsible for the U.S.

---

🧾 2. Policy and operations

Trust & Safety, Seller Performance, and Customer Service all report through North American hubs — primarily in Salt Lake City and Austin.

Canadian-specific policies (e.g., returns, sales tax, bilingual requirements) are adapted by a regional compliance team, not authored locally.

So, Canada’s operational input is consultative, not directive.

---

3. Business strategy

From a financial perspective, Canada represents a small share of eBay’s global GMV (~2–3%), compared to the U.S., UK, and Germany.
Because of that scale difference:

Strategic initiatives tend to be U.S.-first, EU-second, and Canada follows.

Canada’s leadership focus is usually on seller outreach, PR, and category growth (e.g., collectibles, automotive parts) rather than global feature direction.

---

4. Historical context

In the early 2000s, eBay Canada did have more local autonomy — including separate marketing campaigns and local promotions teams — but over time eBay centralized functions in San Jose to reduce duplication.
After ~2014, most of eBay’s international markets moved to a “regional cluster” model, grouping Canada with the U.S. under North America.
As a result, Canada lost much of its independent business ownership.

---

5. Engineering & infrastructure

There’s no dedicated engineering team for eBay Canada; platform changes are developed globally.

Even localized shipping integrations (e.g., Canada Post label tools) are implemented by global logistics engineering teams with local vendor input.

That’s part of why you see delays or mismatched features — the Canadian instance depends on global dev cycles and shared infrastructure.

---

🧭 Summary

Function Primary Ownership Canada’s Role

Product development U.S. (San Jose) Adopts and adapts
Engineering U.S. global teams None locally
Payments & policy U.S. and EU regulatory teams Compliance adaptation
Marketing & partnerships Local Canadian team Limited autonomy
Customer support North America shared services No local control

---

Bottom line

Yes — Canada is functionally led by U.S. business owners within eBay’s North American organization.
The Canadian office manages local relationships and brand positioning, but the product roadmap, operations, and strategy are directed from eBay’s U.S. headquarters.
Message 1 of 7
latest reply
6 REPLIES 6

eBay Canada - a breakdown of the business structure - can it survive?

Here's a chatGPT ESTIMATE of global markets GMV on eBay:

Estimated GMV by localized market (2024, approximate)

> Assumes global GMV = US$74.7B. Percentages are my best guesses based on seller distribution, market size, and known emphasis by eBay.



Market Estimated % of eBay GMV Estimated GMV (USD)

United States 48.0% $35.9B
United Kingdom 12.0% $9.0B
Germany 10.0% $7.5B
China (incl. cross-border listings) 6.0% $4.5B
Australia 4.0% $3.0B
Canada 3.0% $2.2B
Rest of world (all other localized markets combined) 17.0% $12.7B
Total (approx) 100% $74.7B


(Rounded — arithmetic shown uses the $74.7B anchor above.)


---

Why these ranges / uncertainties matter

1. No public country splits. eBay reports U.S. vs. international or regional mixes but not per-country GMV; anything below is inference.


2. Sellers ≠ GMV exactly. Seller headcount shares are a useful proxy but countries with fewer sellers can still drive high GMV (big ticket items, cross-border flows).


3. Cross-border sales blur geography. A UK buyer buying from a US seller will show up in international flows depending on how eBay books GMV.


4. Macro & seasonality. Quarterly variations, FX, and market promotions shift percentages year-to-year (e.g., Q2 2025 GMV ~ $19.5B per quarter).
Message 2 of 7
latest reply

eBay Canada - a breakdown of the business structure - can it survive?

   With respect to business projections I find AI very unreliable. It cannot predict the level of tariffs or the De minimus amounts that may be in place next week let alone next year. This playing field can still change abruptly for the better or for the worse. for the worse there is the initiation of even higher costs due to the coming new additional promoted listing fees.

 

  Considerations:

  • EBay's 3rd quarter financials are extremely impressive.
  • 2 months into zero De minimis & Ebay is investing heavily in Canada's EIS program.
  • Western, Northern and remote communities may suffer and drop off as a result of EIS however more than 90 percent of Canadians and the majority of eBay items are shipped from within 150 miles of the US border. Those sellers may possibly adapt.
  •   I've seen growth in some other online selling platforms that already have a tariff line item as part of checkout.
  • There is already at least one new Canadian online selling upstart advertising on Facebook albeit it looks weak. 

  Had you consulted AI for your "GPT ESTIMATE of global markets GMV on eBay"  in January 2020 (one month before COVID became public) would you have put your faith in it's prediction then? Had you done so you would have not seen the coming online seller's boom. With online selling gong through the roof by the end of Covid AI would have said "Who knew?"

 

 Time, politics, platform resilience and market acceptance aren't yet predictable by AI. That said AI may be able to offer us a more reliable projection about next year's economy in general for Canada, the US and Mexico.

 

  

   

Message 3 of 7
latest reply

eBay Canada - a breakdown of the business structure - can it survive?

byto253
Community Member

Not really anything new in the summary that we didn't know regarding .ca being run and supported out of the US.  

Message 4 of 7
latest reply

eBay Canada - a breakdown of the business structure - can it survive?

Thanks guys for chiming in. I wanted to post this info so others who are shaking their fists at eBay to do things to improve the Canadian reality get an idea why that never happens quickly or as we want it. As well the question I asked was neutral and chatGPT did the hours of scouring legwork for me. It also was very clear in all the information it presented that it was giving estimates, not hard numbers.
Of course things can change rapidly, but one thing is clear, and that is relying on a US centric model will cause eBay harm if it considers it's international business as important. Looks like from the estimates that GMV is roughly 50% for global markets. That's nothing to sneeze at. Canada represents a very small portion, so we'll never get the love the UK, Europe and China do. But as things will inevitably change, the spending power of Canada could improve. The US is looking less interesting for all in global investment as things deteriorate, and Canada is in a position where we can grow. Who knows!
Message 5 of 7
latest reply

eBay Canada - a breakdown of the business structure - can it survive?

Thanks for sharing this information without rancor and frustration.  Much easier to digest the data. Your information did fill some gaps pertaining to my profiling of Ebay.com vis-a vis Ebay.ca

Will Ebay Canada survive. I think so as many Canadians as still invested and will continue to promote

interesting and positive solutions. Is anyone listening? Certainly.

Keep sharing!

Message 6 of 7
latest reply

eBay Canada - a breakdown of the business structure - can it survive?


@cottagewoman wrote:
Thanks guys for chiming in. I wanted to post this info so others who are shaking their fists at eBay to do things to improve the Canadian reality get an idea why that never happens quickly or as we want it. As well the question I asked was neutral and chatGPT did the hours of scouring legwork for me. It also was very clear in all the information it presented that it was giving estimates, not hard numbers.
Of course things can change rapidly, but one thing is clear, and that is relying on a US centric model will cause eBay harm if it considers it's international business as important. Looks like from the estimates that GMV is roughly 50% for global markets. That's nothing to sneeze at. Canada represents a very small portion, so we'll never get the love the UK, Europe and China do. But as things will inevitably change, the spending power of Canada could improve. The US is looking less interesting for all in global investment as things deteriorate, and Canada is in a position where we can grow. Who knows!

I suspect Canada is actually a little higher than the estimates since many people were listing on the USA site with location set to the USA, which is now changing. I wouldn't be surprised if it was around 4%, similar to Australia. Bringing in eIS will also make eBay more attractive for new businesses to use as well, especially as the list of countries grows.

Message 7 of 7
latest reply